|
 Log in |
Register
|
|
 Head To Head The Modern Antiquarian Cairn W Forum | Start a topic | Search |
13 messages | Select a forum: |
CianMcLiam wrote: http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/post/71049/cairn_w.html To me, this looks identical to common or garden open air rock art, it is on one of the orthostats of the ruin of Carin W in front of Cairn T, similar markings are on other stones. This would obviously lead to the conclusion that the rock art is earlier, and not from the bronze age. Ken , I agreee that ,the stone in the pic is atypical compared with the rock art found in other passage graves and elsewhere in the Loughcrew cairns , but the others are unlike the usual found in the open air even having a quite distinct style .It is maybe no coincidence that the stone is not in a passage and compares with Newgrange where the open air motifs , cups and circles are found on the exterior kerb and and rarely in the passage or chambers . Deciding whether the carvings were done "for the job " is difficult to prove either way , fwiw , I think the majority were on order but there are later cases like Clava where the marked rocks were probably from a much earlier marked outcrop and saved doing a new one , like Newgrange they certainly wern't carved in situ . I would extend the use of carved rocks from outcrops to use as cist covers , Craig Hill has obvious signs of quarrying as do other sites possibly providing an al frsco cist cover factory . The dating of RA world wide is showing that is much older than previously believed e.g. Lower Paleolithic so Early Neolithic is almost modern .Clive Waddington suggets Mesolithic but with little evidence . Reply | with quote |  22nd October 2008ce 19:43 In reply to: Re-used rock art? (CianMcLiam) |
Messages in this topic: |
|